Sharon and I recently enjoyed an 8-night cruise on the Carnival Spirit. This itinerary features four days at sea with port stops at Acapulco, Zihuatanejo and Manzanillo. While we prefer more upscale cruising, we still had a good time on this voyage.
What we liked best:
--Food in the dining room exceeded my expectations for quality and variety. We had good waiters and several times I relied on their recommendations with good results.
--Evening entertainment: there was a nice assortment of the typical cruise ship song and dance evenings interspersed with comedy and a big band night. The show room was large enough that it was not necessary to arrive early to obtain a seat.
--The water slide appealed to adults and kids alike and provided good exercise climbing up the stairs to try it again and again.
--The ship is in good condition. It has a straightforward layout that is easy to navigate
--San Diego is a great cruise port and I recommend a few days of pre-cruise stay to enjoy it; ship embarkation and debarkation were both smooth and quick.
Areas of disappointment:
--Activities during days at sea are definitely oriented to the ‘sun and fun’ demographic. There were very few activities that are more intellectual than “hairy chest contest”, beanbag toss, bingo and trivia contests (may also be true for Mexican Riviera itineraries of other cruise lines also).
--The breakfast and lunch buffets are a bit of a zoo. The layout is somewhat confusing. However the ‘deli’ station produces very good panini-style sandwiches (especially the reuben) but lines can be long.
The Ports:
--Acapulco: beautiful harbor and convenient docking facility. We began a walk around town starting with the fort (excellent exhibits) but got sidetracked by a tout on our way to old town. For a future visit, I recommend a shore excursion or staying on the ship. Others on the ship enjoyed the cliff divers (we both had seen this on a previous trip).
--Zihuatanejo: a tender port with a pleasant seaside town. Took a cab to Playa la Ropa but wished that we had taken the tender to Playa las Gatas (see cruisecritic.com message boards)..
--Manzanillo: the ship docks in a container port. We took a Carnival shore excursion to Barra de Navidad by bus and it was pleasant. Others took a cab to Las Hadas resort for the day (see cruisecritic.com for a description). There is nothing to do in town.
Tips:
--use the main dining room for breakfasts (any day) and lunches (sea days only) to avoid the crowds in the buffet area. Service was prompt and the experience was far more civilized.
--try the upscale specialty dining restaurant (Nouveau Supper Club) at least once. It might seem a bit pricey at $30/person but the food and service are excellent. Given how little you pay for this cruise, the supper club is a good value for a very nice dining experience.
--the ‘ultimate ship tour’ was thoroughly enjoyed by a couple that dined with us. They saw all sorts of interesting places on the ship and had a chance to speak with several officers. These tours are only given a few times and are limited to 15 guests per tour. The cost is something like $90. Consider it a shore excursion onboard ship.
--the water slide is best on sea day #2 and during port days (limited hours in port). It gets very windy on the last two sea days.
--if you are using ‘anytime’ dining, ask for a table in Ricardo’s section; he is very good. You can switch from fixed dining to anytime dining with a bit of angst by being polite but assertive.
--the self-service ice cream bar sometimes had sundae items added during afternoons
--The Filipino band (Music Network) that plays in the Versailles Lounge does a great job with 50s, 60s and 70s rock covers.
--the ‘farewell party’ on the last sea day was very nice; free drinks and entertainment were provided.
Who would enjoy Carnival:
--Just about anyone who sails with the proper expectations. This itinerary appeals primarily to a ‘sun and fun’ demographic: people that like to drink by the pool, play bingo and hang out in the casino. You are not paying for Holland America/Cunard level of service and you won’t get it. But you can still have a good time
--Families and multi-generation groups were plentiful. The kids program seems to be effective as we didn’t see much of the 300+ kids who were aboard our sold-out cruise.
Who would not enjoy Carnival:
--Someone who strongly prefers a more elegant style of cruising with intellectually stimulating daily activities
--Anyone who would be put off by people wearing shorts and t-shirts at dinner in the main dining room; it appeared that the dress code, if any, wasn’t being enforced on this itinerary.
--Sophisticated travelers should not use Carnival as a first cruise; they should have their first cruise experience on a more up-market cruise line, later using Carnival for a quick getaway.